[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[FW1] Very strange problem with Firewall-1, Radius, HACMP and NOKIA



Hello,
 
i've the following configuration:
 
1) 2 * NOKIAs:  NOKIA650A (internal IP 192.168.186.21) and NOKIA650B (internal IP 192.168.186.22) working in HA with Monitor Circuit.  NOKIA650A has Logical IP address 192.168.186.31 and NOKIA650B has logical IP address 192.168.186.32.
Both of them have FW-1 Version 4.1 SP2.
 
2) 2 * RS/6000 AIX Servers configured with HACMP. Each AIX Server has 2 Ethernet adapters (1 for polling each other, the other for connecting to the LAN). AIX1 has IP 192.168.186.41 and Serves Radius.  AIX2 has IP 192.168.186.42 and Servers HTTP. Both of them have default route NOKIA650B logical address (IP 192.168.186.32).  AIX1 is nated to 222.X.X.41 and AIX2 is nated to 222.X.X.42. If AIX1 failes, then AIX2 gets AIX1 IP and MAC in the second adapter, though AIX2 has IP 192.168.186.42 and 192.168.186.41.  If AIX2 has to initiate a connection, the source IP address is <192.168.186.42> (his own address).
 
3) 2 * External RAS (IP 222.X.X.100 and 222.X.X.101).  Both of them has default route NOKIA650B external logical IP address.  Both of them authenticates to IP 222.X.X.41.
 
4) If Both RS/6000 are up, everything goes OK.  If AIX2 goes down, everythings goes OK too.  But if AIX1 goes down, we begin to see in the Firewall-1 log the following:  Source <222.X.X.100> Dest <192.168.186.41> Service <Radius> dropped by the last rule (Any Any Any drop).  I mean, suddenly the Firewall-1 drops packets that goes to the internal IP address of the Radius Server.  It's OK that the Firewall-1 drops this packets.  WHAT IT'S WRONG is that it's imposible that the RAS sends a packet to a Internal IP address.  We've put a Sniffer between the Firewall-1 and the RAS and we saw that the RAS sends the packets to IP <222.X.X.41>, so it's the Firewall-1 who's having problem with his NAT tables or rules.  What is strange too is that not every packet is dropped:  some are dropped, and others goes to the External IP address of the Radius Server <222.X.X.41>
 
Has anybody had something similar ?
 
Thank's in advance, Leonardo.